MAHONEY’S MOMENTS
Jim has written regular leadership-related blog posts, along with several other leaders, for Ohio University’s Voinovich Academy. On this page, you can read his monthly blog posts, Mahoney’s Moments. These moments are aimed at a variety of topics and the content is designed for the moment and intended to cause you to reflect, perhaps consider an approach, or entertain a new idea in your life or work. Enjoy!
November 2026: Beyond the Scoreboard: What Great Leaders Build
Over the past few months, I’ve had the privilege of watching a remarkable run by the Big Walnut High School girls’ volleyball team, a local school near Columbus. My interest began when the daughter of a longtime colleague started for the team. I caught a few of their regular season matches on their way to a league title, followed them through district and regional championships, and watched them push all the way to the state semifinals. They entered the semifinal match 26-0. They lost in an absolute thriller of close sets. This blog though isn’t about a season that fell just short of perfection. It has nothing to do with the mechanics of volleyball, as I still couldn’t tell you everything a libero does! It’s what I learned from parents, an experienced coach, and players between points, between sets, and before and after each final outcome of the matches:
JOY WAS A COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: Even when trailing between sets in high pressure tournament games, the players weren’t tight, fractured, or pointing fingers. Even after miscues, teammates would congratulate effort and sort of say “forget that last play, let’s get the next one.” They danced to music before games while warming up. They had elaborate, ritualistic greetings for each other that included slapping hands, chest bumping, and feet fiving. They just looked happy to be together.
CONNECTION BEFORE COMPETITION: Before home games the coach and his wife invited players to their home for dinner and discussion. They built trust off the court that carried over when there was pressure on it.
CLASS IN EVERY OUTCOME: Across all the matches I watched, they were consistently humble in victory—and when their undefeated season ended in heartbreak at the state semifinals, they were gracious in defeat.
At the center of all this was a calm, collected 80-year-old head coach. At an age when many stepped back, he was completely present—teaching, encouraging, and guiding his players. There was nothing transactional about his approach. This wasn’t about another title or trophy. His teams have earned scores of these during his five-decade coaching career. He was transforming the lives of teenage girls through the game of volleyball. Here are the leadership lessons I’m taking away from this experience that can be applied widely to any organization.
- CULTURE IS BUILT AT THE DINNER TABLE
I’ve never met this coach, but I promise you his pregame dinners were strategic. Breaking bread together, talking informally, and getting to know each other is trust in the bank for when later times when it’s critical. Solid relationships built overtime sustain unity.
- COMPOSURE IS CONTAGIOUS
When a team faces pressure like I saw last Friday, panic can set in on the floor or sideline. This coach brought calm and confidence as the emotional thermostat for the team. He didn’t bring anxiety and blame to tighten people up. Instead, he chose calm and energy to allow players to perform at their best. I’m sure that composure has contributed to his success over the years.
- RITUALS ARE GLUE
While I never understood the dancing rituals and exuberance of players, I knew these micro rituals were borne of belonging. They signaled that you are valued, seen, and not alone out here on this floor. They welcomed each other and celebrated small wins.
- TRANSACTIONAL LEADERS CHASE WINS; TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERS BUILD PEOPLE
I heard a recent podcast by Coach Nick Saban who said it was while he was at Michigan State that he learned to be a transformational coach. Up until then, he was only about wins. He said his team was playing OSU when his record was 4-4, and comments were being made about firing him. He thought his team had no chance of winning and how could he talk to his team about winning when he didn’t think they could. He called a psychologist who advised him to talk about winning moments, their relationships, and taking one step at a time. He said they beat OSU, and that he began his new method of transformational leading. The result for him was that his team won 90% of games after that. The volleyball coach I watched does that too. You don’t get to 26-0 by accident. You get there with people playing for each other.
- HOW YOU LOSE REVEALS WHAT YOU BUILT
It is easy to be positive when you win. How you show up when you lose a heartbreaking match shows character. The fact that these young women handled their loss with the same grace they handled their wins shows their culture wasn’t built on a scoreboard. Coach had anchored their identity in effort, gratitude, and how to treat others. The loss didn’t break them.
These kids will long remember this season, but I suspect for what was accomplished, not what was lost. Congrats Eagles!